Vice President, Workers Compensation Claims

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.

The Vice President role at AmTrust is a lucrative opportunity for experienced claims professionals, but it comes with high expectations and demands.

Last checked on June 11, 2026. We may earn a commission when you click through.

This position is ideal for seasoned professionals looking to advance in the insurance sector, but it may not suit those new to the field.

✓ High salary potential ✓ Robust benefits including life insurance ✓ Focus on career development

Vice President, Workers Compensation Claims

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.

Updated 2 days ago

Apply now →

You'll be redirected to talent.com

Princeton $401k

This position is ideal for seasoned professionals looking to advance in the insurance sector, but it may not suit those new to the field.

About this role

The Vice President role at AmTrust is a lucrative opportunity for experienced claims professionals, but it comes with high expectations and demands.

About the Company

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. is a global provider of property and casualty insurance, specializing in workers' compensation and other commercial insurance solutions.

Key Highlights

✓ Competitive salary of $401,000
✓ Comprehensive benefits package including health and dental plans
✓ 401k savings plans with employer match
✓ Opportunities for career advancement
✓ Support for dependent care and flexible spending

💡 Honest Take: While the salary and benefits are attractive, the role demands strong leadership and experience in claims management, which may limit applicants.

Pros

✓ High salary potential
✓ Robust benefits including life insurance
✓ Focus on career development
✓ Located in a vibrant community

Cons

✗ High expectations for leadership experience
✗ Role may involve significant stress
✗ Requires on-site presence in Princeton

Best For: Ideal for candidates with a strong background in workers' compensation claims and a desire for career growth.

Watch Out: Be prepared for a demanding work environment that requires significant expertise in claims management.

Apply for this position →

You'll be redirected to talent.com

What Customers Say

Current employees appreciate the competitive compensation but note the challenges of high-pressure expectations.

Expert Review

The role of Vice President at AmTrust Financial Services comes with a hefty salary of $401,000, making it a compelling option for seasoned professionals. The position demands not just leadership but deep expertise in managing workers' compensation claims, which can be a steep hill for those without prior experience.

AmTrust stands out with a comprehensive benefits package that includes medical and dental plans, life insurance coverage for dependents, and a 401k savings plan with employer matching. This structure supports a strong work-life balance, important for high-stress roles like claims management.

However, the job isn't for everyone. The high expectations for leadership can be daunting, and the Princeton location means candidates must be prepared for on-site responsibilities. Those new to the industry may find the demands overwhelming.

According to the official job listing (https://www.talent.com/redirect?acquisition_sub_id=10101&bpid=f00c0c38eb5f7835768f2bcbba24cf00&channel_1=default&channel_2=default&channel_3=default&context=api&eligible=yes&falcon=1&id=881cc122d0ac&initiator=First+Command+Financial+Services%2C+Inc.&is_gl=0&l=New+York&pc=6&pid=6dc0009a28cd&publisher=7c2b7e61c1&puid=3de83de8gddfgaddfadd3def3deebdde9adceddg3aef3aed3ee33de83ee33beb3bed3cec3ee33def3de93de93de73deg3deg3ded3def3de7gddgeed33de93deb&rdr=&sdb=3&search_id=21aad29b511c4295fb02d4db3f551cd6&source=RubikTech&testid=sonicCPCFloorTolerance20&utm_campaign=arbitrage&utm_medium=api&utm_product=7c2b7e61c1), this position offers promising career advancement opportunities, appealing to those looking to elevate their careers in the insurance field.

🏢